The Crime of Independence
By FREDERICO FUENTES
CounterPunch
At the centre of the Summit of the Americas held in Trinidad and Tobago over April 17-19, was the only country from the hemisphere not present — Cuba.
Speaking at the opening session, Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega noted that while a large majority of the heads of states of the Americas were present, “there are two major absentees”.
The first was “Cuba, whose crime has been to fight for its independence, for the sovereignty of the peoples; lending solidarity, without conditions, to our peoples, and for that it is being sanctioned, for that it is being punished, for that it is being excluded.”
The second was the nation of Puerto Rico, which continues to be an official colony of the United States — denied independence.
In 1962, Cuba was expelled from the Organisation of American States for having openly declared the nature of its revolution to be socialist — based on the ideology of “Marxism-Leninism”.
Despite its exclusion, Cuba’s presence was felt at the summit.
In his April 4 column, “Why is Cuba being excluded?”, former Cuban president Fidel Castro explained that Ortega “gave me a large number of paragraphs that are being debated about the final declaration of the upcoming Port of Spain Summit”.
Arguing that there were “a great number of inadmissible concepts”, he said that the summit would be a “litmus test for the peoples of the Caribbean and Latin America”.
Cuban President Raul Castro attended the Bolivarian Alternatives for Our Americas (ALBA) Summit in Cumana, Venezuela, over April 16-17, in which the anti-imperialist bloc sought to “prepare its artillery”.
The ALBA countries (Venezuela, Cuba, Bolivia, Nicaragua, Honduras and Dominica) issued a public document declaring their opposition to the draft declaration of the Summit of the Americas.
Part of the reason was the exclusion of Cuba and the refusal of the US to lift its nearly five decade-long economic blockade.
At the summit, Latin American president after president denounced the US blockade and called for Cuba’s inclusion in the summit. Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez proposed the next summit be held in Havana.
Others raised the need for an Organisation of Latin American and Caribbean States, including Cuba but not the US or Canada.
The March decisions by the Costa Rican and El Salvadoran government to renew diplomatic ties with Cuba left the US as the only country in the Americas without official ties with Cuba’s socialist government. This is a long way from previous decades, when only a handful of regional governments kept links and the OAS backed US anti-Cuba policy.
In light of this hemispheric shift, the Obama administration recently moved to lift travel restrictions to Cuba for Cubans living in the US. It also eased restrictions on remittances from Cuban immigrants in the US sent home.
However, Obama remains firm on keeping the US blockade, despite speculation of more changes to come..
On April 20, the Washington Post reported Obama as saying: “The policy that we’re had in place for 50 years hasn’t worked the way we want it to.”
This is because, Obama said, “The Cuban people are not free”.
But, as Shamus Cooke noted in PEJ News that same day, the “purpose of the embargo is not to pressure Cuba into being more democratic: this lie can be easily refuted by the numerous dictators the U.S. has supported in the hemisphere, not to mention dictators the U.S. is currently propping up all over the Middle East and elsewhere”.
The real cause of continued US hostility is that “Cuba remains a solid source of pride” for the continent.
Cuba achieved impressive social gains, including an extensive and completely free education system and a lower infant mortality rate than the US. It has achieved these gains despite the US blockade and the economic crisis caused by the collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s.
The US government and its apologists accuse Cuba of a lack of democracy.
Cuba’s system is not perfect. However, not only is access to housing, jobs, education and health care (guaranteed in Cuba) pre-requisites for democratic participation, Cuba’s political system is based on “people’s power”. Cuban citizens are able to exercise significant control over the system — including the right to recall elected officials.
“Where is there more democracy, in the United States or in Cuba?”, Chavez said. “Who has the democracy meter? I have no doubt that there is more democracy in Cuba than in the United States.”
Speaking at the ALBA summit, Bolivian President Evo Morales said, “The US has no right or authority to speak of democracy, because they are the ones that foster coups”. He said Cuba exercises a democracy, in which million-dollar electoral campaigns don’t exist.
Cuba’s crime is the political and economic independence won through the revolution.
Cooke said: “Defeating the U.S. Bay of Pigs invasion [in 1961] while remaining fiercely independent in a region dominated by U.S. corporations and past government interventions has made Cuba an inspiration to millions of Latin Americans. This profound break from U.S. dominance — in its ‘own backyard’ no less — is not so easily forgiven.
“There is also a deeper reason for not removing the embargo. The foundation of the Cuban economy is arranged in such a way that it threatens the most basic philosophic principle shared by the two-party system: the market economy (capitalism).”
Cooke said that “the current crisis of world capitalism is again posing the question: is there another way to organize society?”
Frederico Fuentes writes for Green Left Weekly.
Tecpatl
4/28/09
¿Cómo explicar que la fiebre porcina sea curable en EU y en México no?
Le Monde y el virus
Yuriria Iturriaga
La Jornada
En el diario francés Le Monde, el articulista Hervé Morin escribió ayer en su artículo Alerta mundial contra nuevo virus gripal, ciertas ideas que resumimos a continuación:
Actualmente los focos de infección humana por un virus de gripa hasta ahora desconocido –de origen porcino– aparecidos en Estados Unidos y en México, y que han causado varias decenas de muertes en este último país, parecen bajo control en Estados Unidos, donde se registraron ocho casos entre finales de marzo y el 24 de abril, fecha en que el Centro de Control de Enfermedades (CDC, por sus siglas en inglés) precisó que los pacientes fueron moderadamente afectados, aunque uno fue hospitalizado.
“Contrariamente a México –escribe Morin– donde ha habido más de un millar de enfermos y 20 decesos formalmente atribuidos al nuevo virus H1N1, lo que provocó medidas de urgencia, como la anulación de cursos escolares y universitarios, sin que las autoridades sepan por cuánto tiempo se prolongarán las restricciones, o incluso si convendrá confinar en sus domicilios al conjunto de la población.”
Y continúa, tras advertir que “las autoridades francesas de salud pública se reúnen para reflexionar sobre las medidas a tomar para los turistas que regresen de México.
“El agente infeccioso, virus de influenza A de tipo H1N1, desconcierta a los expertos. Muy contagioso pero poco peligroso en el animal y rara vez identificado en el hombre, para quien ha sido hasta ahora excepcionalmente mortal, no se ha encontrado vínculo evidente entre las personas infectadas y la cría de puercos, dándose por cierto que el virus no se transmite por la ingesta de su carne (…)
Y más enigmático aún: los primeros análisis muestran que la cepa que ataca en México es idéntica a la que se encontró en California. ¿Cómo explicar que sea mortal al sur del río Bravo y curable al norte? Lo ignoramos aún, confesó un vocero de la Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS), quien vacilaba en declarar la pandemia.
Mientras que “para el director general de la Organización Mundial de la Salud Animal, Bertrand Vallat, conviene no pronunciar conclusiones precipitadas (…) a la vez que constata: siendo el nuevo virus sensible a antivirales recientes, se podrían fabricar vacunas rápidamente, pero ello sustituiría la producción de vacunas contra la gripa de estación que mata hasta un millón de personas en el mundo. Pero habría qué escoger... (…) Con mayor razón –prosigue Morin– cuando uno de los raros casos de infección mortal humana por gripe porcina, en 1976, sólo mató a un soldado en 1976 en Nueva Jersey, lo que desató una vacunación masiva que a la larga parece haber provocado casos de polineuritis aguda autoinmune (síndrome de Guillain-Barré) algunos de ellos mortales”.
Yuriria Iturriaga
La Jornada
En el diario francés Le Monde, el articulista Hervé Morin escribió ayer en su artículo Alerta mundial contra nuevo virus gripal, ciertas ideas que resumimos a continuación:
Actualmente los focos de infección humana por un virus de gripa hasta ahora desconocido –de origen porcino– aparecidos en Estados Unidos y en México, y que han causado varias decenas de muertes en este último país, parecen bajo control en Estados Unidos, donde se registraron ocho casos entre finales de marzo y el 24 de abril, fecha en que el Centro de Control de Enfermedades (CDC, por sus siglas en inglés) precisó que los pacientes fueron moderadamente afectados, aunque uno fue hospitalizado.
“Contrariamente a México –escribe Morin– donde ha habido más de un millar de enfermos y 20 decesos formalmente atribuidos al nuevo virus H1N1, lo que provocó medidas de urgencia, como la anulación de cursos escolares y universitarios, sin que las autoridades sepan por cuánto tiempo se prolongarán las restricciones, o incluso si convendrá confinar en sus domicilios al conjunto de la población.”
Y continúa, tras advertir que “las autoridades francesas de salud pública se reúnen para reflexionar sobre las medidas a tomar para los turistas que regresen de México.
“El agente infeccioso, virus de influenza A de tipo H1N1, desconcierta a los expertos. Muy contagioso pero poco peligroso en el animal y rara vez identificado en el hombre, para quien ha sido hasta ahora excepcionalmente mortal, no se ha encontrado vínculo evidente entre las personas infectadas y la cría de puercos, dándose por cierto que el virus no se transmite por la ingesta de su carne (…)
Y más enigmático aún: los primeros análisis muestran que la cepa que ataca en México es idéntica a la que se encontró en California. ¿Cómo explicar que sea mortal al sur del río Bravo y curable al norte? Lo ignoramos aún, confesó un vocero de la Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS), quien vacilaba en declarar la pandemia.
Mientras que “para el director general de la Organización Mundial de la Salud Animal, Bertrand Vallat, conviene no pronunciar conclusiones precipitadas (…) a la vez que constata: siendo el nuevo virus sensible a antivirales recientes, se podrían fabricar vacunas rápidamente, pero ello sustituiría la producción de vacunas contra la gripa de estación que mata hasta un millón de personas en el mundo. Pero habría qué escoger... (…) Con mayor razón –prosigue Morin– cuando uno de los raros casos de infección mortal humana por gripe porcina, en 1976, sólo mató a un soldado en 1976 en Nueva Jersey, lo que desató una vacunación masiva que a la larga parece haber provocado casos de polineuritis aguda autoinmune (síndrome de Guillain-Barré) algunos de ellos mortales”.
4/27/09
Mr. President, Calderon is Not Mexico
A Dance of Avoidance
By LAURA CARLSEN
CounterPunch
President Obama's visit to Mexico has produced vague and contradictory statements, centered on worn-out strategies. Many people who had hoped for a new approach that would seek to redress the inequities of the binational relationship will find little in these declarations to pin their hopes on.
Obama began by enthusiastically endorsing President Felipe Calderon. He expressed his "admiration" for Calderon's "courage" in the increasingly bloody drug war and went so far as to promote Calderon's bid to host the next UN Climate Change meeting.
These overtures no doubt served to decrease tensions between the two governments that built up following U.S. statements of Mexico as a near "failed state" that was losing a grip on its own territory to drug cartels, and a potential national security threat. But by focusing the trip on the person of Calderon and seeking to bolster his leadership rating, Obama forgets that Calderon is a polemical president in a deeply divided nation as a result of both his rightwing policies and the doubts of legitimacy that hang over his presidency.
Obviously, Calderon is Obama's formal counterpart but the unnecessary accolades rankle among the 50% of the population who felt defrauded by his court-determined ascendency to office. Note that Calderon did not spend time praising the person of Obama who, in fact, was not his preferred candidate in the 2008 elections.
The proposals held forth by the two presidents for the most part were either too vague to evaluate or did not respond to the needs of their respective publics. Calderon offered proposals to deepen NAFTA by building infrastructure on the border to increase economic flows, reforms in customs rules, and elimination of tariff and non-tariff barriers. In doing so, he fell back on the debunked argument that by competing as a bloc in an unregulated global economy, both countries will someday enjoy prosperity. This at a time when that model has collapsed, leaving millions of people out of work on both sides of the border.
Meanwhile, Mexican peasant farmers who have been forced off their land by U.S. imports were preparing a demonstration to call for renegotiation of the agricultural chapter of the agreement.
As predicted, both presidents confirmed their commitment to a militarized and unsuccessful "war on drugs" in Mexico. Obama did state that the binational relationship should not be defined only by security issues, but in terms of real programs—of putting one's money where one's mouth is—that remains the case. The Merida Initiative increased aid to Mexico tenfold in one area—security. This model, which employs the army to cut off the supply of illegal drugs, has no record of success in any part of the world. On the other hand, we know it causes extensive environmental damage, violence, displacement, violation of human rights, and curtailment of civil liberties.
The energy and "green jobs" proposals were unclear. Mexicans are wary of proposals to commit energy resources in the way that the Canadians have had to under NAFTA and there is also considerable criticism of carbon markets as a market-based alternative to needed regulation on polluting emissions.
The bright spot on the horizon of this troubled U.S.-Mexico relationship is the issue of immigration. Obama reiterated his commitment to legalization of Mexican undocumented workers established north of the border, while paying some penalties. Recent news stories indicate that he is moving on this commitment. Calderon offered no concrete proposals to generate or preserve jobs in areas of high expulsion nor did Obama offer proposals in this crucial area.
Up to now, both have avoided controversial issues—the renegotiation of NAFTA, corruption, inequality or, directly, the economic crisis. They did not speak of specific measures to generate employment in Mexico or alleviate the crushing poverty that affects millions of Mexican families.
The involvement of the U.S. government in Mexico's national security apparatus, advanced through the Merida Initiative—the military and police aid package designed by the Bush administration and passed by Congress, raises sensitive issues of sovereignty. Tagging on measures within the United States does not erase those fears or the ill-conceived emphasis on Mexico's part of the transnational problem.
Likewise, good intentions and empty declarations do not resolve the problem of the profound asymmetries and inequalities locked in by NAFTA that feed migration from Mexico to the United States.
These issues will be a part of the agenda at the Summit of the Americas. There, the alternatives to corporate-led globalization that are being developed throughout the hemisphere will have a central place, putting into relief the failure of the old models.
Presidents Obama and Calderon have an obligation to revise their proposals and seek a "new era" that really responds to the multiple crises—economic, financial, environmental, social, and security—that characterize this moment in the binational relationship.
Laura Carlsen is director of the Americas Policy Program in Mexico City. She can be reached at: (lcarlsen(a)ciponline.org).
By LAURA CARLSEN
CounterPunch
President Obama's visit to Mexico has produced vague and contradictory statements, centered on worn-out strategies. Many people who had hoped for a new approach that would seek to redress the inequities of the binational relationship will find little in these declarations to pin their hopes on.
Obama began by enthusiastically endorsing President Felipe Calderon. He expressed his "admiration" for Calderon's "courage" in the increasingly bloody drug war and went so far as to promote Calderon's bid to host the next UN Climate Change meeting.
These overtures no doubt served to decrease tensions between the two governments that built up following U.S. statements of Mexico as a near "failed state" that was losing a grip on its own territory to drug cartels, and a potential national security threat. But by focusing the trip on the person of Calderon and seeking to bolster his leadership rating, Obama forgets that Calderon is a polemical president in a deeply divided nation as a result of both his rightwing policies and the doubts of legitimacy that hang over his presidency.
Obviously, Calderon is Obama's formal counterpart but the unnecessary accolades rankle among the 50% of the population who felt defrauded by his court-determined ascendency to office. Note that Calderon did not spend time praising the person of Obama who, in fact, was not his preferred candidate in the 2008 elections.
The proposals held forth by the two presidents for the most part were either too vague to evaluate or did not respond to the needs of their respective publics. Calderon offered proposals to deepen NAFTA by building infrastructure on the border to increase economic flows, reforms in customs rules, and elimination of tariff and non-tariff barriers. In doing so, he fell back on the debunked argument that by competing as a bloc in an unregulated global economy, both countries will someday enjoy prosperity. This at a time when that model has collapsed, leaving millions of people out of work on both sides of the border.
Meanwhile, Mexican peasant farmers who have been forced off their land by U.S. imports were preparing a demonstration to call for renegotiation of the agricultural chapter of the agreement.
As predicted, both presidents confirmed their commitment to a militarized and unsuccessful "war on drugs" in Mexico. Obama did state that the binational relationship should not be defined only by security issues, but in terms of real programs—of putting one's money where one's mouth is—that remains the case. The Merida Initiative increased aid to Mexico tenfold in one area—security. This model, which employs the army to cut off the supply of illegal drugs, has no record of success in any part of the world. On the other hand, we know it causes extensive environmental damage, violence, displacement, violation of human rights, and curtailment of civil liberties.
The energy and "green jobs" proposals were unclear. Mexicans are wary of proposals to commit energy resources in the way that the Canadians have had to under NAFTA and there is also considerable criticism of carbon markets as a market-based alternative to needed regulation on polluting emissions.
The bright spot on the horizon of this troubled U.S.-Mexico relationship is the issue of immigration. Obama reiterated his commitment to legalization of Mexican undocumented workers established north of the border, while paying some penalties. Recent news stories indicate that he is moving on this commitment. Calderon offered no concrete proposals to generate or preserve jobs in areas of high expulsion nor did Obama offer proposals in this crucial area.
Up to now, both have avoided controversial issues—the renegotiation of NAFTA, corruption, inequality or, directly, the economic crisis. They did not speak of specific measures to generate employment in Mexico or alleviate the crushing poverty that affects millions of Mexican families.
The involvement of the U.S. government in Mexico's national security apparatus, advanced through the Merida Initiative—the military and police aid package designed by the Bush administration and passed by Congress, raises sensitive issues of sovereignty. Tagging on measures within the United States does not erase those fears or the ill-conceived emphasis on Mexico's part of the transnational problem.
Likewise, good intentions and empty declarations do not resolve the problem of the profound asymmetries and inequalities locked in by NAFTA that feed migration from Mexico to the United States.
These issues will be a part of the agenda at the Summit of the Americas. There, the alternatives to corporate-led globalization that are being developed throughout the hemisphere will have a central place, putting into relief the failure of the old models.
Presidents Obama and Calderon have an obligation to revise their proposals and seek a "new era" that really responds to the multiple crises—economic, financial, environmental, social, and security—that characterize this moment in the binational relationship.
Laura Carlsen is director of the Americas Policy Program in Mexico City. She can be reached at: (lcarlsen(a)ciponline.org).
Crisis sanitaria: dimensiones e implicaciones
Editorial de La Jornada
La Jornada
En una conferencia de prensa realizada en la residencia oficial de Los Pinos, el titular de la Secretaría de Salud federal, José Ángel Córdova Villalobos, señaló que hasta el momento se han registrado en el país 81 muertes probablemente relacionadas con el brote del nuevo virus de influenza porcina –identificado el pasado viernes– y señaló que se encuentran internados unos mil 300 pacientes con los síntomas de esta enfermedad. Ante ello, anunció que las actividades escolares de todos los niveles, así como los servicios de guarderías, se suspenderán hasta el próximo 6 de mayo en el Distrito Federal, el estado de México y San Luis Potosí, entidad esta última en la que se han contabilizado cinco muertes vinculadas con la gripe porcina. Durante la misma reunión, el titular de la Secretaría de Economía, Gerardo Ruiz Mateos, informó que no se suspenderán las actividades productivas en el país frente al brote de influenza.
Además del aspecto estrictamente sanitario, la presente emergencia tiene una inocultable dimensión económica, y es obligado señalar que el objetivo del gobierno federal de no parar las actividades productivas en las zonas afectadas por el virus se enfrentará al temor y la incertidumbre que acusan amplios sectores de la población. En un momento en que México padece los efectos de una grave crisis financiera de escala planetaria, la reactivación de la economía y el mercado internos se presenta como medida por demás necesaria. Este objetivo, sin embargo, se complica cuando los habitantes de la capital y los municipios conurbados –zona donde buena parte de la actividad económica se concentra en el comercio y los servicios– se resisten a salir a la calle ante el temor de contraer la enfermedad.
Es claro, por lo demás, que la crisis sanitaria que hoy se vive en México y en algunas regiones de Estados Unidos constituye en sí misma un factor de riesgo para la economía nacional y mundial: vale la pena recordar las estimaciones realizadas el año pasado por el Banco Mundial, en el sentido de que una pandemia de influenza significaría la pérdida de unos tres billones de dólares y redundaría en una caída cercana a 5 por ciento del producto interno bruto global. Las autoridades del país deberán tener estas consideraciones en mente y encontrar una manera de equilibrar las medidas adoptadas para solucionar la emergencia sanitaria con la necesidad de alentar el crecimiento económico.
En otro orden de ideas, no puede dejar de advertirse que el decreto emitido ayer mismo por el Ejecutivo federal y publicado en el Diario Oficial de la Federación –que, entre otras cosas, faculta a las autoridades sanitarias para aislar a a los posibles infectados por el virus de la influenza porcina y a ingresar a todo tipo de local o casa habitación para el cumplimiento de actividades dirigidas al control y combate de la epidemia– pudiera tener efectos contraproducentes en los ámbitos político y social. Nadie puede negar la pertinencia de que en una situación de emergencia como la presente las autoridades adopten medidas orientadas a llevar a cabo sus tareas de manera más eficiente, sobre todo cuando está en juego la salud de la población. No obstante, esto no puede ni debe pasar por medidas que, en caso de no ser manejadas con la transparencia y el cuidado que se requiere, pudieran provocar un comprensible descontento entre la población e incluso redundar en acciones violatorias de los derechos y las libertades ciudadanas.
En suma, la actual emergencia sanitaria plantea la necesidad de que las autoridades de todos los niveles de gobierno exhiban sensibilidad, mesura e inteligencia, así como comprensión cabal de todas las dimensiones y de los impactos de la problemática que se enfrenta, y que actúen en consecuencia.
La Jornada
En una conferencia de prensa realizada en la residencia oficial de Los Pinos, el titular de la Secretaría de Salud federal, José Ángel Córdova Villalobos, señaló que hasta el momento se han registrado en el país 81 muertes probablemente relacionadas con el brote del nuevo virus de influenza porcina –identificado el pasado viernes– y señaló que se encuentran internados unos mil 300 pacientes con los síntomas de esta enfermedad. Ante ello, anunció que las actividades escolares de todos los niveles, así como los servicios de guarderías, se suspenderán hasta el próximo 6 de mayo en el Distrito Federal, el estado de México y San Luis Potosí, entidad esta última en la que se han contabilizado cinco muertes vinculadas con la gripe porcina. Durante la misma reunión, el titular de la Secretaría de Economía, Gerardo Ruiz Mateos, informó que no se suspenderán las actividades productivas en el país frente al brote de influenza.
Además del aspecto estrictamente sanitario, la presente emergencia tiene una inocultable dimensión económica, y es obligado señalar que el objetivo del gobierno federal de no parar las actividades productivas en las zonas afectadas por el virus se enfrentará al temor y la incertidumbre que acusan amplios sectores de la población. En un momento en que México padece los efectos de una grave crisis financiera de escala planetaria, la reactivación de la economía y el mercado internos se presenta como medida por demás necesaria. Este objetivo, sin embargo, se complica cuando los habitantes de la capital y los municipios conurbados –zona donde buena parte de la actividad económica se concentra en el comercio y los servicios– se resisten a salir a la calle ante el temor de contraer la enfermedad.
Es claro, por lo demás, que la crisis sanitaria que hoy se vive en México y en algunas regiones de Estados Unidos constituye en sí misma un factor de riesgo para la economía nacional y mundial: vale la pena recordar las estimaciones realizadas el año pasado por el Banco Mundial, en el sentido de que una pandemia de influenza significaría la pérdida de unos tres billones de dólares y redundaría en una caída cercana a 5 por ciento del producto interno bruto global. Las autoridades del país deberán tener estas consideraciones en mente y encontrar una manera de equilibrar las medidas adoptadas para solucionar la emergencia sanitaria con la necesidad de alentar el crecimiento económico.
En otro orden de ideas, no puede dejar de advertirse que el decreto emitido ayer mismo por el Ejecutivo federal y publicado en el Diario Oficial de la Federación –que, entre otras cosas, faculta a las autoridades sanitarias para aislar a a los posibles infectados por el virus de la influenza porcina y a ingresar a todo tipo de local o casa habitación para el cumplimiento de actividades dirigidas al control y combate de la epidemia– pudiera tener efectos contraproducentes en los ámbitos político y social. Nadie puede negar la pertinencia de que en una situación de emergencia como la presente las autoridades adopten medidas orientadas a llevar a cabo sus tareas de manera más eficiente, sobre todo cuando está en juego la salud de la población. No obstante, esto no puede ni debe pasar por medidas que, en caso de no ser manejadas con la transparencia y el cuidado que se requiere, pudieran provocar un comprensible descontento entre la población e incluso redundar en acciones violatorias de los derechos y las libertades ciudadanas.
En suma, la actual emergencia sanitaria plantea la necesidad de que las autoridades de todos los niveles de gobierno exhiban sensibilidad, mesura e inteligencia, así como comprensión cabal de todas las dimensiones y de los impactos de la problemática que se enfrenta, y que actúen en consecuencia.
Wide Open to Pandemic?
Foolish Employment and Health Policies
By DAVE LINDORFF
CounterPunch
The outbreak of a new swine flu in Mexico, and the potential threat of a new global pandemic, shines a bright light on a major weakness in the United States—an employment system where most workers are not paid or even face getting let go if they get sick and have to stay home from work, combined with a broken healthcare system where roughly one in six people have no ready access to a doctor.
What the American failure to mandate employer-paid sick-days means is that most Americans who don’t feel well go to work anyway, in part for fear of losing their jobs, and in part because they are already living so close to the margin that they cannot afford to miss a few days’ pay.
The result of this is that offices, buses, subway cars and elevators in coming weeks will be full of highly infectious people who really should be home trying to recuperate. So even if your employer does offer you sick leave, you will be placed at risk by other employers who do not offer that benefit to their workers, or even by lower-status workers at your own company who don’t get the same sick-pay benefits you do. (At Temple University where my wife works, it was only recently, after a long struggle backed by student activists, that contractor-service guards on the campus received sick pay. Before that, they had to come to work, sick or not, putting students and faculty at risk of infection.)
Add to this the fact that nearly 50 million Americans earn too much to qualify for Medicaid, yet work for employers who don’t provide them with any health insurance. For such people, going to a doctor is a serious problem. They probably don’t have the $50-$100 in cash to pay for an office visit—much less the $200-400 it would cost to bring all four members of a family—and going to an emergency room at a local hospital and asking for charity care for something like flu symptoms could mean a half day in a waiting room (with a lot of other sick people!). Not to mention that many hospitals cheat on their free care provision mandate and then dun patients for $2000 for seeing a nurse-practitioner and getting the advice to take two aspirins and drink a lot of fluid. And then of course, there’s coming up with the money to buy a costly drug like Tamiflu.
Who’s likely to do any that without health insurance?
And so, as this latest round of flu starts to spread inexorably northward from Mexico, we can expect to see it sweep through our workplaces, and on into our schools, causing misery and no doubt a large number of deaths that never should have happened.
The joke here, though it is hardly funny, is that businesses will end up suffering as their workforces are sidelined for weeks, and as the larger economy, already in a deep recession, suffers a further blow. Sick workers don’t earn money, and thus have less to spend, and besides, when whole families are laid up and feeling miserable, they are not likely to go out on shopping sprees even if they do have money in their pockets.
It doesn’t have to be like this. An enlightened country would mandate that all employers offer their employees a minimum of one week’s paid sick leave per year, so that people could stay home if they came down with something. This benefit could be made cumulative, so that a worker would be incentivized not to abuse the benefit, and could use it in the event of a longer illness or injury.
An enlightened country would also see the self-interest for all in having a health system that provided care for all. It’s not just a matter of human decency, though one would hope that would be enough. It’s also in our own interest that the person who sits next to us in the office or on the bus have health insurance and ready access to a doctor when needed.
At a bare minimum, the federal government should set up free neighborhood clinics able to provide primary health care in every community where it is determined that there is a lack off access to physicians.
While we’re at it, school systems should also not be penalized if students miss days at school because of illness. At present, having students stay home for medical reasons reduces a school’s federal funding, as grants are based upon a formula that counts student days per year. This formulaic approach may lead school administrators to avoid calling for school cancellations at a time of a possible epidemic.
Hopefully this outbreak of swine flu will turn out to be nothing serious. But it should nonetheless serve as a wake-up call to the American public. The next crisis could be a serious outbreak of human-to-human bird flu, or a dramatic increase in drug-resistant Tuberculosis or who knows what other communicable disease.
And when it comes to communicable diseases, we had better accept that we have to be our brothers’ keepers or we will become their vectors instead.
Dave Lindorff is a Philadelphia-based journalist and columnist. His latest book is “The Case for Impeachment” (St. Martin’s Press, 2006 and now available in paperback). He can be reached at dlindorff@mindspring.com
By DAVE LINDORFF
CounterPunch
The outbreak of a new swine flu in Mexico, and the potential threat of a new global pandemic, shines a bright light on a major weakness in the United States—an employment system where most workers are not paid or even face getting let go if they get sick and have to stay home from work, combined with a broken healthcare system where roughly one in six people have no ready access to a doctor.
What the American failure to mandate employer-paid sick-days means is that most Americans who don’t feel well go to work anyway, in part for fear of losing their jobs, and in part because they are already living so close to the margin that they cannot afford to miss a few days’ pay.
The result of this is that offices, buses, subway cars and elevators in coming weeks will be full of highly infectious people who really should be home trying to recuperate. So even if your employer does offer you sick leave, you will be placed at risk by other employers who do not offer that benefit to their workers, or even by lower-status workers at your own company who don’t get the same sick-pay benefits you do. (At Temple University where my wife works, it was only recently, after a long struggle backed by student activists, that contractor-service guards on the campus received sick pay. Before that, they had to come to work, sick or not, putting students and faculty at risk of infection.)
Add to this the fact that nearly 50 million Americans earn too much to qualify for Medicaid, yet work for employers who don’t provide them with any health insurance. For such people, going to a doctor is a serious problem. They probably don’t have the $50-$100 in cash to pay for an office visit—much less the $200-400 it would cost to bring all four members of a family—and going to an emergency room at a local hospital and asking for charity care for something like flu symptoms could mean a half day in a waiting room (with a lot of other sick people!). Not to mention that many hospitals cheat on their free care provision mandate and then dun patients for $2000 for seeing a nurse-practitioner and getting the advice to take two aspirins and drink a lot of fluid. And then of course, there’s coming up with the money to buy a costly drug like Tamiflu.
Who’s likely to do any that without health insurance?
And so, as this latest round of flu starts to spread inexorably northward from Mexico, we can expect to see it sweep through our workplaces, and on into our schools, causing misery and no doubt a large number of deaths that never should have happened.
The joke here, though it is hardly funny, is that businesses will end up suffering as their workforces are sidelined for weeks, and as the larger economy, already in a deep recession, suffers a further blow. Sick workers don’t earn money, and thus have less to spend, and besides, when whole families are laid up and feeling miserable, they are not likely to go out on shopping sprees even if they do have money in their pockets.
It doesn’t have to be like this. An enlightened country would mandate that all employers offer their employees a minimum of one week’s paid sick leave per year, so that people could stay home if they came down with something. This benefit could be made cumulative, so that a worker would be incentivized not to abuse the benefit, and could use it in the event of a longer illness or injury.
An enlightened country would also see the self-interest for all in having a health system that provided care for all. It’s not just a matter of human decency, though one would hope that would be enough. It’s also in our own interest that the person who sits next to us in the office or on the bus have health insurance and ready access to a doctor when needed.
At a bare minimum, the federal government should set up free neighborhood clinics able to provide primary health care in every community where it is determined that there is a lack off access to physicians.
While we’re at it, school systems should also not be penalized if students miss days at school because of illness. At present, having students stay home for medical reasons reduces a school’s federal funding, as grants are based upon a formula that counts student days per year. This formulaic approach may lead school administrators to avoid calling for school cancellations at a time of a possible epidemic.
Hopefully this outbreak of swine flu will turn out to be nothing serious. But it should nonetheless serve as a wake-up call to the American public. The next crisis could be a serious outbreak of human-to-human bird flu, or a dramatic increase in drug-resistant Tuberculosis or who knows what other communicable disease.
And when it comes to communicable diseases, we had better accept that we have to be our brothers’ keepers or we will become their vectors instead.
Dave Lindorff is a Philadelphia-based journalist and columnist. His latest book is “The Case for Impeachment” (St. Martin’s Press, 2006 and now available in paperback). He can be reached at dlindorff@mindspring.com
Campaña libertad y justicia para Atenco
La Campaña expuso su demanda de la Libertad a los 12 presos políticos ante los hechos en Atenco en 2006
Atenco Libertad y Justicia
Integrantes del Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra (FPDT) junto con representantes de organizaciones de la sociedad civil participantes en la Campaña LIBERTAD y Justicia para ATENCO, nos reunimos el día de hoy con el representante en México de la Oficina de la Alta Comisionada de Naciones Unidas para los Derechos Humanos, Alberto Brunori. En el encuentro, los representantes de las organizaciones civiles y sociales dieron a conocer las acciones de la Campaña orientada a lograr la libertad de los presos políticos y la justicia para Atenco.
Durante la reunión, representantes del FPDT, el abogado Leonel Rivero y el Director del Centro de Derechos Humanos Miguel Agustín Pro, Luis Arriaga Valenzuela, destacamos las violaciones a derechos humanos perpetradas durante los operativos del 3 y 4 de mayo de 2006, la condiciones carcelarias de los presos, así como la importancia de apoyar la solicitud para el traslado del penal federal de alta seguridad del Altiplano a un penal estatal.
Este caso es de interés para la Oficina en México de la Oficina de la Alta Comisionada de Naciones Unidas para los Derechos Humanos debido al seguimiento que realiza a la situación de los derechos humanos en el país y por su actividad para el fortalecimiento de la sociedad y el establecimiento de mecanismos que promuevan las obligaciones del Estado en la materia.
Como ha sido documentado por diversas organizaciones civiles, la incursión policial a San Salvador Atenco los días 3 y 4 de mayo de 2006 tuvo enormes repercusiones en materia de derechos humanos. Arrojó un saldo de 207 detenidos, dos jóvenes asesinados, medio centenar de mujeres que sufrieron violaciones, abusos sexuales, tortura y cateos ilegales. Lamentablemente, todas estas violaciones a los derechos fundamentales siguen impunes.
Como resultado de estos mismos hechos, 12 personas han sido sentenciadas injustamente, acusadas por el delito de secuestro equiparado. De estos casos, tres resultan de mayor gravedad debido a la dureza, irregularidad e ilegalidad de los procesos y condenas. Sin embargo en todos es clara la intencionalidad política, dado el uso que del sistema de justicia se ha hecho para inhibir la exigencia de derechos por parte del Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra.
Quienes participamos en esta Campaña hemos acudido a la Oficina en México de la OACNUDH a fin de que el gobierno mexicano reconozca su responsabilidad en los hechos. Sólo de esta manera podrá el Estado mexicano ser consecuente con la imagen que se ha forjado en el ámbito internacional como un actor relevante en materia de derechos humanos. Un liderazgo que no se refleja efectivamente en las condiciones de vida existentes en México, las cuales, desafortunadamente, parecen cada día menos favorables para la vigencia de los derechos humanos.
Atentamente
Samuel Ruiz García Obispo emérito de la Diócesis San Cristóbal de las Casas, Raúl Vera Obispo de la diócesis de Saltillo, Coahuila, Fray Miguel Concha Malo director del Centro de Derechos Humanos Fray Francisco de Vitoria, Ofelia Medina actriz, Manu Chao músico, Julieta Egurrola actriz, Adolfo Gilly académico, Adriana Roel actriz, Ricardo Rocha periodista, Carlos Montemayor escritor, Francisco Toledo pintor, Diego Luna actor, Roco Pachukote vocalista de la banda de rock Maldita Vecindad y los hijos del Quinto Patio, Daniel Giménez Cacho actor, Luis Villoro filósofo, Marta Verduzco actriz, Rubén Albarrán vocalista de la banda de rock Café Tacaba, Luis Javier Garrido, académico, Bruno Bichir actor, Paco Ignacio Taibo II escritor, periodista, Luisa Huertas actriz, Miguel Angel Granados Chapa periodista, Demián Bichir actor, Verónica Langer actriz, Luis Hernández Navarro periodista, Jorge Zarate actor, Emma Dib actriz, Antonio Ramírez Chávez pintor, Gloria Domingo Manuel “Domi” pintora, Los de Abajo banda de ska y rock, Las Reinas Chulas actrices. Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra, Familiares de presos y perseguidos; Centro de Derechos Humanos Miguel Agustín Pro Juárez, Centro Nacional de Comunicación Social (CENCOS), Colectivo de Abogados Zapatistas (CAZ), Comité Cerezo, Comité Monseñor Romero, Consorcio para el diálogo parlamentario y la equidad; Mujeres Sin Miedo, La Voladora Radio, Servicios legales, Investigación y Asesoría Jurídica, Servicios y asesoría para la Paz (SERAPAZ)
y 130 organizaciones estudiantiles, sindicales, civiles, religiosas, de: Baja California, Coahuila, Chiapas, Chihuahua, Distrito Federal, estado de México, Guerrero, Jalisco, Hidalgo, Michoacán, Morelos, Nuevo León, Oaxaca, Puebla, San Luis Potosí, Sonora, Quintana Roo, Querétaro, Sinaloa, Yucatán y también de Argentina, Alemania, Australia, Bélgica, Brasil, Catalunya, Colombia, Estados Unidos, Francia y Uruguay.
Encuentro de la Campaña Internacional LIBERTAD y Justicia para ATENCO con el representante en México de la OACNUDH
Atenco Libertad y Justicia
Integrantes del Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra (FPDT) junto con representantes de organizaciones de la sociedad civil participantes en la Campaña LIBERTAD y Justicia para ATENCO, nos reunimos el día de hoy con el representante en México de la Oficina de la Alta Comisionada de Naciones Unidas para los Derechos Humanos, Alberto Brunori. En el encuentro, los representantes de las organizaciones civiles y sociales dieron a conocer las acciones de la Campaña orientada a lograr la libertad de los presos políticos y la justicia para Atenco.
Durante la reunión, representantes del FPDT, el abogado Leonel Rivero y el Director del Centro de Derechos Humanos Miguel Agustín Pro, Luis Arriaga Valenzuela, destacamos las violaciones a derechos humanos perpetradas durante los operativos del 3 y 4 de mayo de 2006, la condiciones carcelarias de los presos, así como la importancia de apoyar la solicitud para el traslado del penal federal de alta seguridad del Altiplano a un penal estatal.
Este caso es de interés para la Oficina en México de la Oficina de la Alta Comisionada de Naciones Unidas para los Derechos Humanos debido al seguimiento que realiza a la situación de los derechos humanos en el país y por su actividad para el fortalecimiento de la sociedad y el establecimiento de mecanismos que promuevan las obligaciones del Estado en la materia.
Como ha sido documentado por diversas organizaciones civiles, la incursión policial a San Salvador Atenco los días 3 y 4 de mayo de 2006 tuvo enormes repercusiones en materia de derechos humanos. Arrojó un saldo de 207 detenidos, dos jóvenes asesinados, medio centenar de mujeres que sufrieron violaciones, abusos sexuales, tortura y cateos ilegales. Lamentablemente, todas estas violaciones a los derechos fundamentales siguen impunes.
Como resultado de estos mismos hechos, 12 personas han sido sentenciadas injustamente, acusadas por el delito de secuestro equiparado. De estos casos, tres resultan de mayor gravedad debido a la dureza, irregularidad e ilegalidad de los procesos y condenas. Sin embargo en todos es clara la intencionalidad política, dado el uso que del sistema de justicia se ha hecho para inhibir la exigencia de derechos por parte del Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra.
Quienes participamos en esta Campaña hemos acudido a la Oficina en México de la OACNUDH a fin de que el gobierno mexicano reconozca su responsabilidad en los hechos. Sólo de esta manera podrá el Estado mexicano ser consecuente con la imagen que se ha forjado en el ámbito internacional como un actor relevante en materia de derechos humanos. Un liderazgo que no se refleja efectivamente en las condiciones de vida existentes en México, las cuales, desafortunadamente, parecen cada día menos favorables para la vigencia de los derechos humanos.
Atentamente
Samuel Ruiz García Obispo emérito de la Diócesis San Cristóbal de las Casas, Raúl Vera Obispo de la diócesis de Saltillo, Coahuila, Fray Miguel Concha Malo director del Centro de Derechos Humanos Fray Francisco de Vitoria, Ofelia Medina actriz, Manu Chao músico, Julieta Egurrola actriz, Adolfo Gilly académico, Adriana Roel actriz, Ricardo Rocha periodista, Carlos Montemayor escritor, Francisco Toledo pintor, Diego Luna actor, Roco Pachukote vocalista de la banda de rock Maldita Vecindad y los hijos del Quinto Patio, Daniel Giménez Cacho actor, Luis Villoro filósofo, Marta Verduzco actriz, Rubén Albarrán vocalista de la banda de rock Café Tacaba, Luis Javier Garrido, académico, Bruno Bichir actor, Paco Ignacio Taibo II escritor, periodista, Luisa Huertas actriz, Miguel Angel Granados Chapa periodista, Demián Bichir actor, Verónica Langer actriz, Luis Hernández Navarro periodista, Jorge Zarate actor, Emma Dib actriz, Antonio Ramírez Chávez pintor, Gloria Domingo Manuel “Domi” pintora, Los de Abajo banda de ska y rock, Las Reinas Chulas actrices. Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra, Familiares de presos y perseguidos; Centro de Derechos Humanos Miguel Agustín Pro Juárez, Centro Nacional de Comunicación Social (CENCOS), Colectivo de Abogados Zapatistas (CAZ), Comité Cerezo, Comité Monseñor Romero, Consorcio para el diálogo parlamentario y la equidad; Mujeres Sin Miedo, La Voladora Radio, Servicios legales, Investigación y Asesoría Jurídica, Servicios y asesoría para la Paz (SERAPAZ)
y 130 organizaciones estudiantiles, sindicales, civiles, religiosas, de: Baja California, Coahuila, Chiapas, Chihuahua, Distrito Federal, estado de México, Guerrero, Jalisco, Hidalgo, Michoacán, Morelos, Nuevo León, Oaxaca, Puebla, San Luis Potosí, Sonora, Quintana Roo, Querétaro, Sinaloa, Yucatán y también de Argentina, Alemania, Australia, Bélgica, Brasil, Catalunya, Colombia, Estados Unidos, Francia y Uruguay.
4/25/09
The Fight to Save Mexico's Mangroves
Losing the Lagoons
By KENT PETERSON
CounterPunch
Standing in front of the Vicente Guerrero Elementary School as the children played, Obdulia Balderas recalls when she came to Zihuatanejo in the state of Guerrero more than 40 years ago. A young schoolteacher from the Guerrero town of Taxco, Balderas was haunted by the violence against dissident students and youth by Mexican security forces, who slaughtered hundreds in what has become known as the Tlatleloco Massacre.
Figuring that the quiet port of Zihuatanejo was a safer place and only a stone's throw from Acapulco, Balderas accepted a job as a third-grade teacher. She was surprised to discover that it took hours to reach the little Pacific bay on a winding, dusty dirt road.
Next to the school was a mangrove estuary where the children hauled out a hidden wooden raft and splashed and fished in the water during recess. Fresh water percolated in from a pristine arroyo that entered the bay.
That was in 1968. A few years later the administration of President Luis Echeverria expropriated communally-owned lands for a new tourist development, offering local landowners a small cut of the sales proceeds.
"It hit us like a big drinking binge," Balderas says. "We didn't realize what we were losing. They gave the (landowners) a little bit of money ... everyone felt like they were rich. Some bought a car, others got drunk. But they didn't realize what they were losing."
Today, little remains of Balderas' memories of Zihuatanejo. The mangroves have been torn out, the estuary drained, and the clean water replaced with a stream of water-born contaminants that enter the bay from a cement-lined canal. On the other side of Zihuatanejo's main beach, the dirty wastewater defiles the vestiges of a mangrove ecosystem that stretches to Las Salinas Lagoon. A man was recently charged for cutting down more than five acres of threatened mangrove trees at another local beach, Playa Larga.
Zihuatanejo was an appropriate place for the most recent meeting of the International Mangrove Network (IMN)-Mexico, a section of a network that draws together defenders of mangroves from across the globe. Characterized by lazy waters and droopy trees, mangroves constitute "the first scale of life," says Marco Antonio Rodriguez of Marea Azul, a non-governmental environmental group based in the Mexican state of Campeche on the Gulf of Mexico.
Situated on the coasts of Latin America and much of the tropical world, mangrove estuaries are places where the hum of insects, the splash of fish, the flutter of birds, and the prowl of crocodiles can sometimes still convey a timeless natural world in an age where time is money and space a commodity. Tropical mangroves function to capture carbon, incubate numerous aquatic species, prevent coastal erosion, serve as windbreaks to storms, shelter migratory birds from the north, and nourish coastal communities and cultures, say Rodriguez and other members of the IMN-Mexico.
Threats to Mangrove Ecosystems
In today's Mexico, mangrove ecosystems are under growing pressure. Statistics compiled by Greenpeace Mexico and the federal Ministry of the Environment and Natural Resources report that mangrove habitat in the country's coastal zones fell from 1,041,267 hectares in 1976 to 683,881 in 2007. If present trends continue, Greenpeace Mexico warns, the country will lose an additional 40-50% of its existing mangrove cover by 2025.
The Mexican mangrove story is one that is repeated across the world. A 2001 report from the World Rainforest Movement noted that half the planet's mangroves vanished during the latter part of the 20th century.
Alejandro Olivera, ocean and coastal campaign coordinator for Greenpeace Mexico, says mangroves contain important economic value for fishing and coastal economies. A study done in the Gulf of California by Mexico's National Fisheries Service, Olivera says, reported that each hectare (2.6 acres) of mangroves generates $37,500 in economic value.
For the members of the Barra de Santa Ana Cooperative in the Mexican Pacific state of Michoacan, mangroves sustained the shrimp harvest in the past and could embrace an eco-tourism project in the future. Co-op members plan to build cabins and take tourists on boat excursions to view crocodiles and other wildlife.
"We've created the ecotourism project to satisfy the necessities of our families," says co-op Secretary Hector Madrigal. "We're only lacking the authorization of the appropriate authorities."
Madrigal and friends maintain a mangrove nursery, planting 5,000 new trees last year. A similar mangrove reforestation effort is underway in the Tres Palos Lagoon near Acapulco, with the support of the city government and local fishermen.
Tourist development, the construction of residential subdivisions in urban centers like Acapulco, new ports on the Pacific Coast, Pemex facilities in the Gulf of Mexico, and contamination of estuaries from heavy metals, pesticides, and other chemicals all pose serious threats to Mexico's mangroves.
Despite opposition from tourism developers, a tough new law protecting mangroves was approved by the Mexican Congress in 2007. Two years later, pressures to develop coastal tourism and trade, especially in tough economic times, are encouraging efforts to gut the law. According to Greenpeace's Olivera, two initiatives in the Mexican Congress could elevate development over environmental protection. "We're worried," Olivera acknowledges. Activists are campaigning to make sure the 2007 law stays intact.
The "Climate Change President" and Destruction of the Mangroves
While President Felipe Calderon and members of his administration make speeches about Mexico being a world leader in reducing greenhouse gases and blunting climate change, environmentalists warn that pro-development policies will destroy an essential ecosystem that guards against the effects of climate change as well as climate change itself.
Mangroves could become a tragic casualty of the rush to trade in the country's coasts for dollars. Calderon recently inaugurated the Pacific Coast Planned Integral Center (CIP) in Sinaloa. Located in the middle of an extensive mangrove forest, the new tourism project is envisioned to be twice the size of Cancun and attract 3 million tourists annually according to Miguel Gomez Font, director of Mexico's National Tourism Promotion Fund. Gomez claims the project will grow a city of 500,000 people and create 150,000 jobs.
In a February speech inaugurating the project in Escuinapa, Sinaloa, President Calderon pledged the mega-project will respect the environment. But Gabriel Martinez Campos, president of the Colima-based environmental organization Bios Iguana, criticizes President Calderon for unveiling the CIP without first having a required environmental impact assessment.
"With this decision, the government of Felipe Calderon creates a legal uncertainty and allows investors who want to become established in the country an open door to come in without any administrative or legal pressure," Martinez says. "We are now in a situation where ecocide is an action of the state, and there is going to be impunity in the environmental arena."
Earlier this year, Bios Iguana co-filed a complaint with the Montreal-based North American Commission on Environmental Cooperation (CEC) over another project—the massive expansion of the Pacific port of Manzanillo. Manzanillo is a key link in China-North America trade where plans are underway to construct a liquefied natural gas (LGN) re-gasification terminal operated by the Federal Electricity Commission as well as a second LNG facility run by the Ciudad Juarez-based Zeta Gas Company.
The complaint contends the development will jeopardize the Cuyutlan Lagoon, one of the richest mangrove habitats of Mexico's Pacific Coast, as well as jeopardize the safety of nearby residents. Approved by the national environmental ministry, the local municipal development plan facilitates port and terminal construction—all in violation of Mexican environmental law, the complaint alleges.
Conflicts of Interests
CEC Executive Director Adrian Vasquez recused himself from involvement in the Manzanillo complaint. Vasquez's Mexican citizenship as well as his former service as a Mexican government official drove the decision. A chemist by trade who graduated from the University of Texas at El Paso, Dr. Vasquez previously worked in neighboring Ciudad Juarez and the state of Chihuahua both as an environmental regulatory official and as a consultant to private industry. Zeta Gas is one of the most ubiquitous and influential firms in northern Mexico. Dr. Vazquez also recused himself from participating in another CEC case filed by Chihuahua activists opposed to the planting of genetically-modified corn.
Both the Manzanillo and Chihuahua cases are currently under review in the CEC.
Set up as the environmental side commission of the North American Free Trade Agreement, the CEC does not have the authority to order changes in the Manzanillo project. After reviewing the complaint, the CEC could decide to investigate and deliver statement of facts to Mexican environmental authorities, who would then have the discretion to alter the project or not.
Environment Secretary Juan Rafael Elvira Quezada has called preserving mangroves a "priority task for the current administration," but members of IMN-Mexico contend the federal agency lacks the needed resources and political muscle to be effective.
"On the one hand they have humanistic principles and principles of being Mexican nationalists," says Marco Antonio Rodriguez. "On the other hand, they have interests they cannot overcome."
Perhaps an emblematic case in point involves the former chief of environmental office for the state of Guerrero, Leonel Lozano. Lozano was fired from his post last February after running afoul of tourism developers. The showdown erupted after Lozano filed three legal complaints against the planned Bungalows Playa Azul tourist development near Acapulco.
In response, lawyers for the development pursued a formal complaint against Lozano, alleging he trespassed on private property and exceeded his authority as a government official. Subsequently, the internal affairs division of Mexico's federal government determined Lozano should be sacked from his job.
Insisting he was within legal limits, Lozano says he ran across violations during one of his routine inspections of the Guerrero countryside. Lozano maintains Bungalows Playa Azul had encroached upon the prohibited federal zone near the beach, partially filling a lagoon with construction material and erecting buildings in a "high risk" area for natural disasters where a lagoon meets the Pacific Ocean.
According to the Acapulco daily El Sur, the Federal Attorney General for Environmental Protection shut down the Bungalows Play Azul site shortly after Lozano's firing because the development was found to have exceeded its environmental permit.
Lozano's firing hit the national press, got attention in the Mexican Congress, and provoked outrage among Guerrero environmentalists, including members of the IMN-Mexico. Although a 2008 article in an Acapulco magazine promoting Bungalows Playa Azul bore the logo of the Guerrero state government, Governor Zeferino Torreblanca later publicly disassociated his administration from the project.
A full plate on their table, members and supporters of IMN-Mexico from 47 organizations, the Guerrero state government, and Zihuatanejo municipal governments concluded a meeting in the Pacific town last month. More than 100 people heard research presentations, networked with fellow environmentalists, and issued a statement, "The Zihuatanejo Declaration."
Besides redoubling their commitment to protecting mangrove zones, the signers of the declaration opposed the proposed La Parota Dam near Acapulco, expressed solidarity with Mexican environmentalists facing state repression, and called for public clarification of the Lozano firing.
Signatories of the Zihuatanejo Declaration included the Zihuatanejo Network of Environmental Organizations, Oaxaca Coastal Wetlands Network, Greenpeace Mexico, Bios Iguana, Marea Azul, and SOS Bahia, among many others. The statement addressed Latin American and international issues, including a controversial petrochemical project slated for Venezuela's Paraguana Peninsula, which has been proposed as a biosphere reserve in the United Nations.
While expressing solidarity with environmental policies of the Venezuelan government, the Zihuatanejo Declaration conveyed concern about a massive development project intended with support from China and Iran.
The Zihuatanejo event was originally planned as a Latin American gathering but was stymied by Mexican immigration authorities, according to Colima mangrove defender Esperanza Salazar. Although conference planners submitted paperwork months in advance in order to obtain visas for a delegate from El Salvador and one from Colombia, Salazar insists, immigration officials finally refused to issue the necessary travel permits. The conference co-organizer blames current Mexican policies that cast suspicion on certain foreign nationals who might attempt to remain in Mexico or try to cross the border into the United States.
"This is very grave for the people," Salazar says, "because it's part of the struggle, and if we aren't together, we can't struggle together."
For Marco Antonio Rodriguez, preserving mangrove ecosystems is an especially urgent task in a world besieged by twin economic and climate crises. Delving into past history as a guide to the future, Rodriguez reaffirmed the sentiments that first brought pro-mangrove activists from Mexico, Ecuador, and Honduras together back in 1995.
"We determined that the only solution was for the people to come together, to form bonds of sisterhood, and to make demands and engage in forms of struggle that permit (people) to conserve the natural resources which sustain their lives and economies," Rodriguez says.
Kent Paterson is a freelance journalist who covers the southwestern United States, Mexico, and Latin America, and an analyst for the Americas Program at www.americaspolicy.org.
By KENT PETERSON
CounterPunch
Standing in front of the Vicente Guerrero Elementary School as the children played, Obdulia Balderas recalls when she came to Zihuatanejo in the state of Guerrero more than 40 years ago. A young schoolteacher from the Guerrero town of Taxco, Balderas was haunted by the violence against dissident students and youth by Mexican security forces, who slaughtered hundreds in what has become known as the Tlatleloco Massacre.
Figuring that the quiet port of Zihuatanejo was a safer place and only a stone's throw from Acapulco, Balderas accepted a job as a third-grade teacher. She was surprised to discover that it took hours to reach the little Pacific bay on a winding, dusty dirt road.
Next to the school was a mangrove estuary where the children hauled out a hidden wooden raft and splashed and fished in the water during recess. Fresh water percolated in from a pristine arroyo that entered the bay.
That was in 1968. A few years later the administration of President Luis Echeverria expropriated communally-owned lands for a new tourist development, offering local landowners a small cut of the sales proceeds.
"It hit us like a big drinking binge," Balderas says. "We didn't realize what we were losing. They gave the (landowners) a little bit of money ... everyone felt like they were rich. Some bought a car, others got drunk. But they didn't realize what they were losing."
Today, little remains of Balderas' memories of Zihuatanejo. The mangroves have been torn out, the estuary drained, and the clean water replaced with a stream of water-born contaminants that enter the bay from a cement-lined canal. On the other side of Zihuatanejo's main beach, the dirty wastewater defiles the vestiges of a mangrove ecosystem that stretches to Las Salinas Lagoon. A man was recently charged for cutting down more than five acres of threatened mangrove trees at another local beach, Playa Larga.
Zihuatanejo was an appropriate place for the most recent meeting of the International Mangrove Network (IMN)-Mexico, a section of a network that draws together defenders of mangroves from across the globe. Characterized by lazy waters and droopy trees, mangroves constitute "the first scale of life," says Marco Antonio Rodriguez of Marea Azul, a non-governmental environmental group based in the Mexican state of Campeche on the Gulf of Mexico.
Situated on the coasts of Latin America and much of the tropical world, mangrove estuaries are places where the hum of insects, the splash of fish, the flutter of birds, and the prowl of crocodiles can sometimes still convey a timeless natural world in an age where time is money and space a commodity. Tropical mangroves function to capture carbon, incubate numerous aquatic species, prevent coastal erosion, serve as windbreaks to storms, shelter migratory birds from the north, and nourish coastal communities and cultures, say Rodriguez and other members of the IMN-Mexico.
Threats to Mangrove Ecosystems
In today's Mexico, mangrove ecosystems are under growing pressure. Statistics compiled by Greenpeace Mexico and the federal Ministry of the Environment and Natural Resources report that mangrove habitat in the country's coastal zones fell from 1,041,267 hectares in 1976 to 683,881 in 2007. If present trends continue, Greenpeace Mexico warns, the country will lose an additional 40-50% of its existing mangrove cover by 2025.
The Mexican mangrove story is one that is repeated across the world. A 2001 report from the World Rainforest Movement noted that half the planet's mangroves vanished during the latter part of the 20th century.
Alejandro Olivera, ocean and coastal campaign coordinator for Greenpeace Mexico, says mangroves contain important economic value for fishing and coastal economies. A study done in the Gulf of California by Mexico's National Fisheries Service, Olivera says, reported that each hectare (2.6 acres) of mangroves generates $37,500 in economic value.
For the members of the Barra de Santa Ana Cooperative in the Mexican Pacific state of Michoacan, mangroves sustained the shrimp harvest in the past and could embrace an eco-tourism project in the future. Co-op members plan to build cabins and take tourists on boat excursions to view crocodiles and other wildlife.
"We've created the ecotourism project to satisfy the necessities of our families," says co-op Secretary Hector Madrigal. "We're only lacking the authorization of the appropriate authorities."
Madrigal and friends maintain a mangrove nursery, planting 5,000 new trees last year. A similar mangrove reforestation effort is underway in the Tres Palos Lagoon near Acapulco, with the support of the city government and local fishermen.
Tourist development, the construction of residential subdivisions in urban centers like Acapulco, new ports on the Pacific Coast, Pemex facilities in the Gulf of Mexico, and contamination of estuaries from heavy metals, pesticides, and other chemicals all pose serious threats to Mexico's mangroves.
Despite opposition from tourism developers, a tough new law protecting mangroves was approved by the Mexican Congress in 2007. Two years later, pressures to develop coastal tourism and trade, especially in tough economic times, are encouraging efforts to gut the law. According to Greenpeace's Olivera, two initiatives in the Mexican Congress could elevate development over environmental protection. "We're worried," Olivera acknowledges. Activists are campaigning to make sure the 2007 law stays intact.
The "Climate Change President" and Destruction of the Mangroves
While President Felipe Calderon and members of his administration make speeches about Mexico being a world leader in reducing greenhouse gases and blunting climate change, environmentalists warn that pro-development policies will destroy an essential ecosystem that guards against the effects of climate change as well as climate change itself.
Mangroves could become a tragic casualty of the rush to trade in the country's coasts for dollars. Calderon recently inaugurated the Pacific Coast Planned Integral Center (CIP) in Sinaloa. Located in the middle of an extensive mangrove forest, the new tourism project is envisioned to be twice the size of Cancun and attract 3 million tourists annually according to Miguel Gomez Font, director of Mexico's National Tourism Promotion Fund. Gomez claims the project will grow a city of 500,000 people and create 150,000 jobs.
In a February speech inaugurating the project in Escuinapa, Sinaloa, President Calderon pledged the mega-project will respect the environment. But Gabriel Martinez Campos, president of the Colima-based environmental organization Bios Iguana, criticizes President Calderon for unveiling the CIP without first having a required environmental impact assessment.
"With this decision, the government of Felipe Calderon creates a legal uncertainty and allows investors who want to become established in the country an open door to come in without any administrative or legal pressure," Martinez says. "We are now in a situation where ecocide is an action of the state, and there is going to be impunity in the environmental arena."
Earlier this year, Bios Iguana co-filed a complaint with the Montreal-based North American Commission on Environmental Cooperation (CEC) over another project—the massive expansion of the Pacific port of Manzanillo. Manzanillo is a key link in China-North America trade where plans are underway to construct a liquefied natural gas (LGN) re-gasification terminal operated by the Federal Electricity Commission as well as a second LNG facility run by the Ciudad Juarez-based Zeta Gas Company.
The complaint contends the development will jeopardize the Cuyutlan Lagoon, one of the richest mangrove habitats of Mexico's Pacific Coast, as well as jeopardize the safety of nearby residents. Approved by the national environmental ministry, the local municipal development plan facilitates port and terminal construction—all in violation of Mexican environmental law, the complaint alleges.
Conflicts of Interests
CEC Executive Director Adrian Vasquez recused himself from involvement in the Manzanillo complaint. Vasquez's Mexican citizenship as well as his former service as a Mexican government official drove the decision. A chemist by trade who graduated from the University of Texas at El Paso, Dr. Vasquez previously worked in neighboring Ciudad Juarez and the state of Chihuahua both as an environmental regulatory official and as a consultant to private industry. Zeta Gas is one of the most ubiquitous and influential firms in northern Mexico. Dr. Vazquez also recused himself from participating in another CEC case filed by Chihuahua activists opposed to the planting of genetically-modified corn.
Both the Manzanillo and Chihuahua cases are currently under review in the CEC.
Set up as the environmental side commission of the North American Free Trade Agreement, the CEC does not have the authority to order changes in the Manzanillo project. After reviewing the complaint, the CEC could decide to investigate and deliver statement of facts to Mexican environmental authorities, who would then have the discretion to alter the project or not.
Environment Secretary Juan Rafael Elvira Quezada has called preserving mangroves a "priority task for the current administration," but members of IMN-Mexico contend the federal agency lacks the needed resources and political muscle to be effective.
"On the one hand they have humanistic principles and principles of being Mexican nationalists," says Marco Antonio Rodriguez. "On the other hand, they have interests they cannot overcome."
Perhaps an emblematic case in point involves the former chief of environmental office for the state of Guerrero, Leonel Lozano. Lozano was fired from his post last February after running afoul of tourism developers. The showdown erupted after Lozano filed three legal complaints against the planned Bungalows Playa Azul tourist development near Acapulco.
In response, lawyers for the development pursued a formal complaint against Lozano, alleging he trespassed on private property and exceeded his authority as a government official. Subsequently, the internal affairs division of Mexico's federal government determined Lozano should be sacked from his job.
Insisting he was within legal limits, Lozano says he ran across violations during one of his routine inspections of the Guerrero countryside. Lozano maintains Bungalows Playa Azul had encroached upon the prohibited federal zone near the beach, partially filling a lagoon with construction material and erecting buildings in a "high risk" area for natural disasters where a lagoon meets the Pacific Ocean.
According to the Acapulco daily El Sur, the Federal Attorney General for Environmental Protection shut down the Bungalows Play Azul site shortly after Lozano's firing because the development was found to have exceeded its environmental permit.
Lozano's firing hit the national press, got attention in the Mexican Congress, and provoked outrage among Guerrero environmentalists, including members of the IMN-Mexico. Although a 2008 article in an Acapulco magazine promoting Bungalows Playa Azul bore the logo of the Guerrero state government, Governor Zeferino Torreblanca later publicly disassociated his administration from the project.
A full plate on their table, members and supporters of IMN-Mexico from 47 organizations, the Guerrero state government, and Zihuatanejo municipal governments concluded a meeting in the Pacific town last month. More than 100 people heard research presentations, networked with fellow environmentalists, and issued a statement, "The Zihuatanejo Declaration."
Besides redoubling their commitment to protecting mangrove zones, the signers of the declaration opposed the proposed La Parota Dam near Acapulco, expressed solidarity with Mexican environmentalists facing state repression, and called for public clarification of the Lozano firing.
Signatories of the Zihuatanejo Declaration included the Zihuatanejo Network of Environmental Organizations, Oaxaca Coastal Wetlands Network, Greenpeace Mexico, Bios Iguana, Marea Azul, and SOS Bahia, among many others. The statement addressed Latin American and international issues, including a controversial petrochemical project slated for Venezuela's Paraguana Peninsula, which has been proposed as a biosphere reserve in the United Nations.
While expressing solidarity with environmental policies of the Venezuelan government, the Zihuatanejo Declaration conveyed concern about a massive development project intended with support from China and Iran.
The Zihuatanejo event was originally planned as a Latin American gathering but was stymied by Mexican immigration authorities, according to Colima mangrove defender Esperanza Salazar. Although conference planners submitted paperwork months in advance in order to obtain visas for a delegate from El Salvador and one from Colombia, Salazar insists, immigration officials finally refused to issue the necessary travel permits. The conference co-organizer blames current Mexican policies that cast suspicion on certain foreign nationals who might attempt to remain in Mexico or try to cross the border into the United States.
"This is very grave for the people," Salazar says, "because it's part of the struggle, and if we aren't together, we can't struggle together."
For Marco Antonio Rodriguez, preserving mangrove ecosystems is an especially urgent task in a world besieged by twin economic and climate crises. Delving into past history as a guide to the future, Rodriguez reaffirmed the sentiments that first brought pro-mangrove activists from Mexico, Ecuador, and Honduras together back in 1995.
"We determined that the only solution was for the people to come together, to form bonds of sisterhood, and to make demands and engage in forms of struggle that permit (people) to conserve the natural resources which sustain their lives and economies," Rodriguez says.
Kent Paterson is a freelance journalist who covers the southwestern United States, Mexico, and Latin America, and an analyst for the Americas Program at www.americaspolicy.org.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Armas
